Showing posts with label judges. Show all posts
Showing posts with label judges. Show all posts

Saturday, March 10, 2012

Dear Season 11


It has been a long time since I have written. Not out of enjoyment over the winner and runner-up last year (Love Scotty and Lauren)..I don't know why, really. I just haven't. Let's not dissect the reasons for my actions.

Let's talk some impressions from this seasons.

First of all, what is up with Steven Tyler? He is pulling a Paula Abdul and suddenly going from "You look nice and sounded great" comments 100% of the time to talking about intervals and calling out the one person he thinks deserves to go home. This is very refreshing to me! I can hear. I know if a contestant was off-key. They can hear. They will know it, too. Perhaps that is argument for just telling them good job, but I think it is more of an argument for being honest. Otherwise, why even have judges.


The top 24 week was the worst judging week ever. Everyone was "Great" according to the judges. It wasn't true! It was so frustrating. You can be nice AND be honest at the same time. Take notes from the judges from the Sing-Off. They manage to be polite while still giving honest feedback. I am just glad Randy dared tell a person or two it was less than stellar and Steven actually had the guts to give an honest answer this week.




Now, whose idea was it to have a bottom 6 this week?!?!?!?! You are putting half of your singers in the bottom? Why? I hope there is some good reason for this. Maybe to wake up complacent voters? You could have at least cut it down to a bottom four instead.

Top 13--I was pleased with the top 13. There was no one left in the 24 that I thought deserved to be there more than any of the 13, though I definitely wouldn't have chosen Deandre. I would have chosen Grim.







What is her name again...let's see...oh yes, Jessica (I should be able to remember that--that is my sister's name). Okay Jimmy--best Idol performace ever? Really? I don't think so.

I do not see the hype with this girl. I see that she is a good singer, but what about her singing sets her apart from a handful of singers already out there who are at least as good if not better? What new does she bring?



Colton is my favorite guy this year.











Phillip is obviously not my favorite guy, however I recognize he is talented and unique enough to possibly win the whole thing.










Elise is my favorite girl. I think she is the most unique.











Skylar is also quite good and I could see her winning.









Jermaine should have come back all nice and humble. Grateful. Instead, he is cocky and seems entitled to me. He obviously thinks he should be there. Here is the major problem with that. American Idol winners are not cocky. They are nice. They are humble. They recognize that other singers are good, too. If he really wants any chance of winning, he needs to get over himself. Or, if I am wrong in my assessment, he needs to figure out how to change the appearance of being full of himself.




Sincerely,
Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Friday, January 21, 2011

New Judges


Dear Judges (namely Jennifer and Steven),

To be perfectly honest, I had written this season off before it even began. I mean, I planned to watch the show to see what I thought, but I was not planning on liking it. No Simon? Not interested. Especially after watching NBCs the Sing-Off--I loved that and decided it could fill my American Idol void.

I typically know the date of the first American Idol episode as soon as it is scheduled. While I knew it was usually the end of January, I had no idea what day the first episode was this year, and didn't care enough to look it up.

Wednesday morning, a friend of mine called.

"I forgot what we think of American Idol this year?"

"Well," I replied, "I think I will watch the first episode, but I am not planning on liking it. I figure I owe it a shot at least."

He then went on to inform me that the first episode was that day. Wow. That is when I realized how disinterested I was. Nevertheless, the DVR was set.

Thursday morning this same friend and his wife stopped by.

"Well, what did you think?"

"Of what?" I inquired.

Oh! American Idol!

I hadn't had a chance to watch it yet. 

That night, I watched it (that would be last night). I then immediately followed it up with the second episode.

Let me tell you, judges, I loved it! I didn't expect to like it, much less love it. No offense to Simon, he made the show great, but the show doesn't need Simon. And you know what? It is kind of refreshing not to have him there. I learned from watching the Sing-Off that judges can be honest AND nice at the same time, something Paula and Simon failed to demonstrate in all of their years on Idol.

So what did I love about it?

For one, I love that the new judges (that is you Jennifer, and you, Steven), are successful performers. This brings in a couple of key elements. One is that they know what it takes to have real success--and not from the management side (maybe you do), but from the performer side.

What else does you being successful do? It ensures that you are confident. You aren't trying to prove anything (cough, cough, Kara). You aren't trying to impress anyone. You might not even care much if Idol doesn't last long for you, I don't know. 

The point is you are interested in the people singing in front of you and not worried about how you look to the viewing public. You don't need to prove you can contribute like Ellen did. You didn't have to prove you had the credibility to comment like Paula did. You didn't have to prove you had the knowledge that Kara did. I mean, you are famous enough that Jennifer Lopez has commercials popping up during the show--you have endorsements, you are famous, you have money, people love you, and you know it.

Another reason I loved it is that it was fun. I loved that the you would sing along (another benefit to you being singers). How great is it to have someone judging your singing be able to sing themselves? It was a lighter atmosphere with fun spontenaeity. Jennifer and Steven, you were so nice! It was great to see niceness. Hopefully you can help Randy swing back to his former nicer self before Simon corrupted him back to middle school days of laughing at people.

Finally, I loved that you were able to look at the talent and past everything else. One woman walked in with a questionable outfit and sang a terrible song. She asked to do another song, and you listened. She was good. Then you told her to lose the gimmicks and believe in her voice. You looked beyond drab clothing to see the potential star behind it all. You didn't tell someone no because they were overweight. You are able to see potential. That was refreshing.

In short, I fully enjoyed the first two episodes and am very excited to see where this season leads!

Sincerely,



Share/Save/Bookmark

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Dear Top 9: My Reactions




Dear Top 9,

Sorry it has taken me so long to write. You know how it gets when the weather is nice and you have a birthday party to plan and all...maybe not the birthday part for most of you.

Anyway, imagine my surprise and dismay to see Andrew in the bottom three--especially after my rant last week. I mean, I know he hasn't given performances true to himself each week, but we all know he is my favorite.

I was not surprised to see Aaron in the bottom three. I was surprised to see Michael there--but mostly because of the judges love for him, not out of reaction toward his singing.

I was surprised to not see Tim there. Really?

In the end, it was Big Mike going home...but then the judges used their save on him.

Can I just say I think that was a mistake?

I really don't think he will win the whole thing. Plus, this is kind of early to be using your one and only save. And in a season full of shockers so far, the judges may live to regret that. What if Crystal, Siobhan, or Lee find themselves going home--unable to be saved? When you still have three people you like more (it seems you do at least), and four weeks to use the save, I think it is a mistake to save him.

We shall see what happens.

Sincerely,

Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Monday, March 29, 2010

Dear Kara: Kissy Face


Dear Kara,

So, I don't know if you have noticed this yet. When you are, I don't know, thinking, listening intently, whatever, you make this kissy face. It is kind of funny and really quirky.

I hate to tell people about their quirks because they will usually change them if they know, but this was so interesting I had to point it out. I like it because I know you are really thinking at that moment.

Sincerely,


Share/Save/Bookmark

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Dear Randy: Stop Booing!


Dear Randy,

I don't know what your deal is. You have done this for as long as I can remember and it is quite annoying. You need to stop booing Simon every time he is introduced.

Okay, I get it. You are jealous of how popular he is. His applause is louder than yours. Contestants say over and over that they respect his opinion while seeming to forget you are even at the table.

But it is just sad to watch you week after week boo him when he is introduced. You are literally the only person in the room booing him. You aren't increasing your popularity, nor are you decreasing his. Just stop. I think the only think I like about the "corny" way the judges are introduced on performance night is that I only have to listen to you boo one night a week instead of two.

Sincerely,
Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Dear Randy: Vitamin D3



Dear Randy,

I don't really know what is going on with you so far this season. You really seem, well, grumpy. You don't like anything...until a pitchy little Aaron comes along (huh?).

Dawg, for me, your judging is really off this season [insert disappointed click with mouth here]. I don't know. It isn't even a'ight man.

Are you feeling down? I know you are in sunny California, but maybe you don't get out enough? Job keeps you in? If that is the case, perhaps you could start taking some Vitamin D3. I think about 2000 IUs a day should do it. Good luck with that. I hope you can come out of your slump.

Sincerely,


Share/Save/Bookmark

Dear Judges: Get Over It


Dear Judges,

I noticed you keep talking about Andrew Garcia's rendition of Straight Up. I was writing to tell you to get over it! Try to look past the past and look at the moment. If you do, you will see that he is doing a great job. You might even notice that practically everyone loves him. Yes, he sang Straight Up. Yes, he did a great job.

But you know what? I still have that song from Fallout Boy in my head three weeks later. The song with Andrew singing it. He has real talent. He is a great singer. I don't need to hear some re-make of some song I thought was cool when I was in third grade to continue liking him.

You are all too hard on him. You seem to be judging people compared to themselves rather than each other. Now, that would be a nice thing to do if this weren't a competition. But it is. To tell Tim he was wonderful just because he was better than he has ever been, and yet he did very little creatively with the song, and then tell Andrew he wasn't very good because it still didn't give you the tingle you got with Straight Up, and yet he did lots with the song, is just getting really frustrating. Maybe you didn't like it as much as Straight Up, but you had to like it better than Hallelujah.

Please get over it.

Thank you.

Sincerely,


Share/Save/Bookmark
Related Posts with Thumbnails