Showing posts with label top 12. Show all posts
Showing posts with label top 12. Show all posts

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Best of Top 12

Dear Readers,

Here are the best of the night.

Scotty


Lauren


Pia


Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Top 12 Perform--Surprising


Dear Top 12,

I was kind of surprised last night. I expected the night to be a hard call, but it was a very, very easy call.

Naima
The vocals were really suffering. I was glad Jennifer finally said something about the pitch issues--you really are better than that (I think). It was not a good night for you.





Paul
You were weak in parts and good in parts. Considering that you were sick, it was great. I am sure you would have done a lot better if you were not sick, and I like that you didn't excuse yourself for being sick.





Thia
Oh the song choice! It was not a good idea. Not at all. You sang it well, but it was nothing memorable other than feeling a bit odd watching a Disney song be sung on American Idol.





James
It was pitchy, but it was the best of the night to that point--though definitely not of the night.






Haley
Okay, I think I have decided that you are a copy-cat singer. The good thing about that is that you are a good singer vocally and that you can sing anything. The really, really bad thing about that is that no one wants to vote for the copy-cat singer. No one knows what kind of album they would get from you if they did, and even if we knew exactly what it would be, we don't need you because we can get those same songs from the original. You need to pick the genre you want to sing in and stick with it--and if you don't know, you will be going home pretty soon.

Stefano
This is definitely the best you have sounded on the show so far. There were no major pitch issues going on. This isn't to say you rocked it, just that you topped yourself.






Pia
No lie, when you started to sing, it was a shock to my ears. In a good way. It was hearing someone who really had a place in the music industry for the first time that night--a singer who could hold her own in the "real world." I didn't love the song--at all--but I loved you singing the song.



Scotty
Another great performance of the night! Really good. The girls loved it, which is always a good thing for votes. I would buy that off of iTunes.






Karen
Very weak. Very pitchy. You have a good voice, but when you put it up next to Pia, very weak.







Casey
It was good. I loved what Randy said, that you are a person who goes for "art first, then commerce." I love that about you. I don't love that song, but you are a great performer. I would love to see you sing something that showed your vocal ability next week and not just your diversity.



Lauren
Very good. I would buy that. It was amazing for the flu, too. I would buy the flu version.







Jacob
There were some pitch issues. It wasn't the worst of the night, but not the best.







Naming my top 3 and bottom 3 is easy this week:

Top Three:

  1. Scotty
  2. Lauren
  3. Pia (I put you third just because I thought the other two did great AND I liked their songs. You did great and I disliked your song--but talent-wise, this top three can be in any order
Bottom Three:
  1. Karen
  2. Naima
  3. Haley
The Rest (from best to worst)--this is definitely slanted by my personal preference for the person him/herself. They all did about the same talent wise, so song choice and my preference is all factored in:
  1. Casey
  2. Paul
  3. Stefano
  4. Thia
  5. James
  6. Jacob
I predict Karen goes home. I do think there is a chance her Spanish singing could have pulled in votes from the Latino community, and if so, then I think Haley will go home due to a dwindling fan base.


Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Thursday, March 18, 2010

Dear Bottom Three: Pleasantly Surprised


Dear Bottom Three,

After last week, I was very pleasantly surprised by the bottom three this week.

Paige: I figured since you wouldn't have Vote For the Worst behind you this week, you would be in the bottom.

Tim: Of course you deserved to be there. You had Vote for the Worst behind you, so I didn't have high hopes. When they took it down to you and Andrew, I was very worried. I felt a bit giddy as I watched you walk across the stage. Nice kid, not a great singer so far as professional singers go, and we are talking about a singing competition.

Lacey: I mentioned in my predications that I wouldn't be upset to see you go. I did think Katie would be in the bottom instead of you. I am wondering who exactly is voting like crazy for her.

All in all, I think all three of you deserved to be there in the bottom three.

Sincerely,
Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Dear Fans: My Predictions


Dear Fellow Fans,

Here are my predictions for tonight. First, there will be some cheesy group number they all lip sing. That is a whole letter by itself. Let's fast forward...

Who will be in the bottom two? Who will go home?

Well, Tim definitely should be the one to go, so of course he is the pick for Vote for the Worst. This means he will most like stay--that coupled with a large number of 12-13 year old girls who are currently imagining what that first moment will be like when they meet Tim face to face for the first time.

So...

My hope is on Paige. I wouldn't be shocked to see Lacey go. I wouldn't feel too bad to see Katie go. Okay, not bad at all.

But last week I was severely shocked. Let's see what happens tonight.

Sincerely, 


Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Dear Top 12: My Reactions


Dear Top 12,

Overall, my reaction to last night is kind of just lukewarm. I think you all did well, but I think only one of you did great. Surprisingly, that one is not my favorite girl Didi, even thought the judges were all over it. Nor is it my favorite guy Andrew, even though he received compliments for the first time since Hollywood. It also is not Siobhan--a clear favorite of the judges. It was Lee. Lee, you were great. Here are some reactions to each individual:

Michael--You sang well. You are fun to watch on stage even if Simon thinks you are corny. But I just really can't see you going far past the American Idol stage. When I think about the genre you are trying to break into, you just don't match up to what is out there. Yes, you are a great singer. If you had come along 10 years ago, you might have done better. But there are plenty of R&B male singers out there.

Didi--In the words of Randy, you know I love you right? So, it wasn't awful. Mostly. But there were parts where you were kind of screaming. I think performance-wise, you did well. I am talking use of stage and your intensity. Vocally, not the best you have done or could do.

Casey--I just am not impressed with you. Maybe someday I will be. You know what? When they were running through the numbers at the end of the show, I honestly had forgotten you had even sung. Really strange for me. And as I type this, I can't remember what you sang.

Lacey--I actually think you did quite well last night. I don't in general really like your singing. Your vowels are much to wide for my taste. But you did well last night.

Andrew--Here is what I didn't like about that song. You weren't true to you. I just can't picture you ever singing that anywhere other than when playing Rock Band or on American Idol--at least not the way you sang it. I mean, on Rock Band you have no choice; you sing it how the disc plays it. But you do have a choice when you are on stage. However, maybe you are just trying to run away from anything related to Straight Up. Maybe you are trying to follow my advice I gave the other day.

Katie--You did a million times better than I expected. But I don't really want that to be criteria for how well you did at the moment. It was okay. It wasn't as horrible as it could have been. I can see potential with you in your singing ability. Some young people can sing ridiculously well (remember Little Davie?). You just need more time to mature. Yeah, I know that is hard to hear sometimes. I remember being 18 and hearing that from the Chamber director my Freshman year of college. But it is true.

Tim--Also not as bad as I thought it would be, but definitely not great. I didn't mind the Raggae vibe. I thought that was creative. But you haven't got the strength of voice other contestants do Unlike Katie, I don't really see time doing a whole lot for you.

Siobhan--Wow. Not a good wow. I am wowing the memory of the judges wowing you. I really disliked that. I liked that the least of all performances last night. Like Simon said, some will love it, others will hate it. I am definitely in the hate it category. He compared you to Adam, which I am sure will make many Adam-lovers mad (like how I got when he compared Pickler to my dear Carrie). You know, Adam wasn't my favorite, but I always could acknowledge that he did a good job. With you, it really sounds like screeching a lot. Really.

Lee--Best of the night. I loved it. Perfect.

Paige--It was okay. One of the bottom performances, though.

Aaron--This was much improved. It was not one of the worst of the night, which surprised me.

Crystal--I liked this one much better than many of your other performances (I really disagreed with the judges a lot last night!). I liked it. I could see me getting on your bandwagon someday maybe.

My Bottom Three:

  1. Tim

  2. Paige

  3. Katie
Siobhan is my least favorite of the night, but I still think she was better than those three.

My Top Three:

  1. Lee

  2. Crystal

  3. Didi
Overall, the group as a whole did well for a Top 12 week I think. I know there is much improvement to come. There weren't any WOW (good wow) moments. Lee did well, but it wasnt' wow. There also weren't any "tilt-my-head-in-effort-to-make-you-sound-better" moments.

Sincerely,

Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Monday, March 15, 2010

Dear Top 12: Some Advice


Dear Top 12,

I have some advice for you. This advice will only be helpful to those who are very savvy...or perhaps just very lucky. I am not sure what it is.

My advice is this: Peak at the right time.

If you peak too early, you will spend the rest of the season chasing after that performance...just ask Andrew about that. Some people still offer amazing performances even after a fantastic peak. But that never pans out, either. Think back to David Archuleta (or "Little Davie" as I call him). He peaked during the Top 24, continued doing well...but by the time the finale rolled around, we were all very impressed but not impressed enough to do anything about it. Some might argue something similar happend with Adam Lambert, but I think with him it was more about the fact that his style didn't mesh with all fans.

Who peaked at the right time? I think the prime example of that is Kris Allen. When the Top 12 started out during Season 8, many of us were saying, "Who is that kid again? That young one who plays the guitar? He won't last long." He did just enough to get by, and then took off at the right moment. Importantly, he had the skills to keep himself sailing after his initial peak.

Another person who peaked well is David Cook. He timed it just right. He took off just as the rest of us were finding Little Davie to be quite predictable (predictably brilliant, but predictable all the same). He played that perfectly.

Another example takes us back all the way to Season One. From the beginning, we all oohed and ahhed over Justin.  He was talented and he knew it. Kelly was great and didn't seem to know it. Her confidence grew, and she kept on climbing right on past Justin.

How do you manage perfect peaking? I am not really sure. Part of it is that you can't bring it all out week one, but you certainly need to bring out enough to stay in the race. Another part is that you need to be able to grow each week; keep improving. Being a frontrunner in this competition is a dangerous place to be. Any frontrunner as a Top 12 member really doesn't win. Stay humble and keep trying to improve yourself. That is the best shot you have at actually winning this thing.

But if you aren't great at strategy and/or just aren't that lucky, don't fret. Plenty of winners have released only one album, while plenty of, uh, not winners? have done very well. A great example of that is Chris Daughtry, who, as place number four, has sold more albums than the three ahead of him combined. There is always hope.

Good luck!

Photobucket

PS I am still hoping this will actually be a Top 13. If Anoop deserved it, Alex sure does!
Share/Save/Bookmark
Related Posts with Thumbnails