Thursday, March 3, 2011

Dear Top 12 Girls

Dear Ladies,

Wow! What an overall great night! The sad thing is that based only on last night, 7 of you more than deserve to make top 12, and if you pull in past performances, that number goes up. In other words, some great people are going to not make it. 

Ta-Tynisa

That was not good. Really not good. I know you are better than that, but with all of the other talent and with the small amount of face time you got before last night, I am pretty confident you will go home tonight.






Naima

Really good performance. I don't think there is anything negative that can be said about it, so great job!







Kendra

I liked it and I really like you.








Rachel

Here is the thing. You sing well, but there is something missing for me. I think in the shadows of the really stand-out performances last night, you will have been lost.






Karen

My husband thought it was funny that they quoted you as saying this competition needed...something about Latin flair or something like that, and then you sang the slow, American ballad. You did throw Spanish in there...but I think it would have been fun to see the Latin flavor you want to show. Overall, good performance, but not a stand-out among the many great performances, so it will probably depend on how solid the Latin vote was behind you.


Lauren T

I love your rich voice.








Ashthon

You are a great singer. I didn't like the song.








Julie

Oh, Julie. You had one of the worst performances of the night. I really like you. I don't know how many votes will be based on last night vs. past experience. For your sake, I hope past experience plays a role.






Haley

You sounded good, which is a compliment since you sang Alicia Keys. My problem with the performance was that it was so theatrical. It seemed so forced and fake--not you.






Thia
REally good performance. Solid, flawless. 

Lauren A
Love you and loved the performance. 

Pia
Somehow, I didn't pay attention to you until last night. That was a really, really good performance and I would agree the best of the night.


So, who do I think will be the top 6?

Lauren A., Pia, Kendra

I think Thia has a great chance at that, too.

I would also say Naima and Haley.

Bottom Two:
Ta-Tynisa and Rachel. I don't think either of you have a shot.

Three that were "eh" for me
Karen, Ashthon, and Julie--however, I would not be shocked to see any of those three in the top 6.





Share/Save/Bookmark

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Dear Top 12 Guys...

Dear Top 12 Guys,

A pretty good night overall! Most of you did really well. Nothing was good enough that I will be buying it off of iTunes, though. But for a first night, lots of goodness going on. 

I must say that I am kind of tired of American Idol changing things up every.single.year at the top 24 stage. Let's find something that works and stick with it.

And let me also say that cutting half of the guys the first week is NOT something that works. I much preferred it back in the day when we cut down to the top 12 more slowly. You can't judge a contestant by one song. Some of these people are being really heard for the first time. Also, some have had a lot of back-story shared while others have had basically none.

Anyway, on to my thoughts from last night.

Clint

I am going to be honest here. I just don't like you because of how you treated JC during group night. That was low. I have never been enamored with your voice, either. However, you did do really well last night.





Jovany

You are a good singer. You hit things nicely. But this isn't state solo and ensemble competition--it is a competition to find someone who can command the charts. That wasn't chart-commanding style. I agreed with Randy on this.





Jordan

Oh Jordan. What happened there? I am not sure why you chose that song. I am hoping you got talked into it by producers (though I do think that is lame). I am not sure why you sang it when you emphatically stated that was not you. I think it is possible you blew it with that. Which just brings me back to not cutting 6 people in one night.




Tim

I really like you Tim. The performance was not a standout and I don't think it really showed you. I am interested to see exactly who you are, so I hope you come through, but there are so many standouts I don't know that there is room for someone who also didn't stand out--especially without a ton of camera time up to this point.




Brett

You did well and you are so quirky. 








James

Not my style, but you did really well and I would be shocked if you didn't make it to the top 12. And I think you deserve to be there.







Robbie

You have a great voice and did well. The song was a bit rushed for my tastes. But with all of the great guys there are, I am not sure if you will come through to the top 12 or not. You sing well, but you also sing very boy band-ish. Of course, that might bode well for you considering the number of young teenage girls who sit on their phones dialing all night long.



Scotty

You are without question my favorite guy. I am excited to have a country singer--a really good country singer--in the mix again. I voted for you! 






Stefano

I don't know what the judges and audience were hearing, because for me, it was so pitchy, it was painful. I was closing my eyes and turning my head. It seem more notes were off than on. 






Paul

Paul, I so enjoy you. You are my number two guy. I made sure to vote for you. I am a bit concerned because the more Indie style singers did not pull through during this stage of the competition. Or, I should say, voters did not pull through. I am really, really hoping you make top 12. You definitely deserve it so far as talent goes. 




Jacob
I am going to go ahead and admit that I am probably one of maybe 5-10 people in the country who does not love you. I am not seeing what the judges are seeing. You did really well last night, yes, but I usually find you far too over the top for me. However, I am positive you will be in the top 12 because if America doesn't put you there, the judges will.




Casey

Wow. So far as musical talent goes, you top the list of all of the contestants--not just the guys. You have amazing skills. I would put you number three in the guys for me. I do wish you had sung more, screamed less last night. I am pretty confident you will be top 12.





So, who do I think will be top 6 guys?

Without question, James, Scottie, Casey, and Jacob. I am really pulling for Paul.

My "I don't think so's" are Jordan and Stefano.

My people I could easily see go either way are Clint, Jovany (but you are on the line of no), Tim, Brett, and Robbie.

My personal ranking if I were the sole choser?

Top 5: Scotty, Paul, Casey, Tim, James

Bottom 4: Stefano, Clint, Jovany, Jordan

Middle 3: Brett, Robbie, Jacob--hard call which of these I would put into top 6.

Share/Save/Bookmark

Friday, January 21, 2011

New Judges


Dear Judges (namely Jennifer and Steven),

To be perfectly honest, I had written this season off before it even began. I mean, I planned to watch the show to see what I thought, but I was not planning on liking it. No Simon? Not interested. Especially after watching NBCs the Sing-Off--I loved that and decided it could fill my American Idol void.

I typically know the date of the first American Idol episode as soon as it is scheduled. While I knew it was usually the end of January, I had no idea what day the first episode was this year, and didn't care enough to look it up.

Wednesday morning, a friend of mine called.

"I forgot what we think of American Idol this year?"

"Well," I replied, "I think I will watch the first episode, but I am not planning on liking it. I figure I owe it a shot at least."

He then went on to inform me that the first episode was that day. Wow. That is when I realized how disinterested I was. Nevertheless, the DVR was set.

Thursday morning this same friend and his wife stopped by.

"Well, what did you think?"

"Of what?" I inquired.

Oh! American Idol!

I hadn't had a chance to watch it yet. 

That night, I watched it (that would be last night). I then immediately followed it up with the second episode.

Let me tell you, judges, I loved it! I didn't expect to like it, much less love it. No offense to Simon, he made the show great, but the show doesn't need Simon. And you know what? It is kind of refreshing not to have him there. I learned from watching the Sing-Off that judges can be honest AND nice at the same time, something Paula and Simon failed to demonstrate in all of their years on Idol.

So what did I love about it?

For one, I love that the new judges (that is you Jennifer, and you, Steven), are successful performers. This brings in a couple of key elements. One is that they know what it takes to have real success--and not from the management side (maybe you do), but from the performer side.

What else does you being successful do? It ensures that you are confident. You aren't trying to prove anything (cough, cough, Kara). You aren't trying to impress anyone. You might not even care much if Idol doesn't last long for you, I don't know. 

The point is you are interested in the people singing in front of you and not worried about how you look to the viewing public. You don't need to prove you can contribute like Ellen did. You didn't have to prove you had the credibility to comment like Paula did. You didn't have to prove you had the knowledge that Kara did. I mean, you are famous enough that Jennifer Lopez has commercials popping up during the show--you have endorsements, you are famous, you have money, people love you, and you know it.

Another reason I loved it is that it was fun. I loved that the you would sing along (another benefit to you being singers). How great is it to have someone judging your singing be able to sing themselves? It was a lighter atmosphere with fun spontenaeity. Jennifer and Steven, you were so nice! It was great to see niceness. Hopefully you can help Randy swing back to his former nicer self before Simon corrupted him back to middle school days of laughing at people.

Finally, I loved that you were able to look at the talent and past everything else. One woman walked in with a questionable outfit and sang a terrible song. She asked to do another song, and you listened. She was good. Then you told her to lose the gimmicks and believe in her voice. You looked beyond drab clothing to see the potential star behind it all. You didn't tell someone no because they were overweight. You are able to see potential. That was refreshing.

In short, I fully enjoyed the first two episodes and am very excited to see where this season leads!

Sincerely,



Share/Save/Bookmark

Monday, May 24, 2010

Dear Lee: I am rooting for you!



Dear Lee,

Hi! Remember me? Yeah, I have still been watching. Just had to send you a little note telling you I am rooting for you. I think you will win unless there is some strange, strange event. You have been super consistent all season long.  I think you are also doing this for the right reason. Crystal said she is doing it for her son, which is great. I have no problems with that. But you are doing it because you love it, and therein lies the huge difference. Your point here is not to make a whole lot of money (though I am sure you won't mind :) ), it is to follow your passion.

I absolutely loved both performances last week. Here they are. They were both amazing.








Best of luck. I will be voting for you!

Sincerely,


Photobucket

Share/Save/Bookmark

Monday, April 19, 2010

Dear Katelyn: My Favorite Moments


Dear Katelyn,

It has been a long time since you have left, but I wanted to share my favorite moments of yours on the show. First, your audtion:



Next, The Scientist. I love this. I have it on my iPod. Every time it comes on, I am struck by how great of a singer you are.


And this cover of the Beetles:


Great stuff Katelyn! I really do hope someone picks you up.



Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Friday, April 16, 2010

Dear Andrew: My Favorite Moments


Dear Andrew,

 I first want to start off by saying what a classy guy you are. The way you reacted when you found out you were voted off was perfect. Here are my favorite moments from you this season. First, your audition:




Then during Hollywood, of course the elusive Straight Up:



Then we had the top 24 performances. I love this, I have it on my iPod:



And my favorite (also on my iPod):



I am excited to see what you bring in the future.

**************And if you want to watch Andrew on Ellen, go to http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-nFrIQ14YVw . A great thing to notice is when Ellen asks him the worst part of Idol and the best part. He starts with the best instead of the worst. He is such a nice guy. *********************

Sincerely,

Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Dear Top 9 (the second): My Reactions This Week


Dear Top 9,

Well, I put off writing about it. Here it is.

My top three favorite were Lee, Crystal, and Mike. Lee, you are fabulous. You are really good and sound effortless.

My middle three were Casey, Katie, and Tim. Yeah, I said Tim. I can't believe he actually sounded good. Tim, your next thing to work on is your phrasing. You don't join things together at all and it was driving me crazy, but other than that, you did a good job.

My bottom three were Andrew, Siobhan, and Aaron. Oh Andrew! I was so worried. I voted! I voted a lot.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~



Then the results night came. Andrew left. Can I just comment on how much class Andrew has? He left with so much class last night. He was upbeat and happy. Naturally, I will have much more in a proper good-bye.

Then Tim and Katie found themselves as the bottom two. And who should leave?



Not the guy. No. It was Katie. I don't feel too bad about it because I don't think she was one of the better singers up there. BUT I must say she improved vastly over the course of the season. She is obviously humble and a hard worker. She has great potential.

Kind of brings you back to wondering "what if" certain people had made it to the top 12 (people named Katelyn, Alex, and Lilly).

Are you wondering who I will be voting for now? It will be Lee. Lee is my new favorite.

Sincerely,
Photobucket

PS--Can I just say I am WAY over the sitting behind the judges thing? Can you all please stop that? Thanks.
Share/Save/Bookmark

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Dear Top 9: My Reactions




Dear Top 9,

Sorry it has taken me so long to write. You know how it gets when the weather is nice and you have a birthday party to plan and all...maybe not the birthday part for most of you.

Anyway, imagine my surprise and dismay to see Andrew in the bottom three--especially after my rant last week. I mean, I know he hasn't given performances true to himself each week, but we all know he is my favorite.

I was not surprised to see Aaron in the bottom three. I was surprised to see Michael there--but mostly because of the judges love for him, not out of reaction toward his singing.

I was surprised to not see Tim there. Really?

In the end, it was Big Mike going home...but then the judges used their save on him.

Can I just say I think that was a mistake?

I really don't think he will win the whole thing. Plus, this is kind of early to be using your one and only save. And in a season full of shockers so far, the judges may live to regret that. What if Crystal, Siobhan, or Lee find themselves going home--unable to be saved? When you still have three people you like more (it seems you do at least), and four weeks to use the save, I think it is a mistake to save him.

We shall see what happens.

Sincerely,

Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Dear {insert right person here}: Stop Being Mean!


Dear People In Charge,

I don't know who decides this, but it must stop. Nearly every single week of this season, you have made it so Andrew is one of the last two when deciding who is in the bottom three (or before the top 12, who is going home). It is getting to be ridiculous. Can't you spread the love? Why do you always make it Andrew? Do you realize that he is quite popular? So you are trying to boost ratings because you think people will get nervous and stay around longer or turn on the TV because they are worried about him? I don't know what it is, but give the poor guy a break! Let someone else sweat it out for once.

Sincerely,


Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Dear Top 9: My Reactions


Dear Top 9,

First of all, Didi gets to stay in the picture for a bit. Second of all, you all did well last night. No one was totally awful. But I also think no one was totally awesome. There wasn't one performance that I will be seeking to purchase off the over-priced iTunes (do you like how I threw that in there?). Here are my reactions and predictions:

Aaron: I didn't like the song and there were some pitch issues. The good thing is that you showed your country edge to your voice, so that will please your country crowd.

Katie: Before you started singing, I told my husband, "This is the song Brooke White sang. There is no way she can top that." When you were done, I declared that you had done really well. That was definitely your best performance ever.

Andrew: First of all, I loved how all the guys said you were their best friend. Everyone's best friend. You sounded good, but it wasn't my favorite performance from you. I won't be buying it. I think I would have liked it better without the horns in the background.

Mike: I really didn't like it. Not much to say beyond that.

Crystal: You did quite well. I was happy to see you be more of yourself. Last week was so strange with the heels and all.

Tim: I fully expected you to blow it as usual, but you sounded good. Randy totally insulted you as he tried to compliment you, but like Simon said, I think you did well even compared to the other contestants.

Casey: So my neighbor, who is a good singer and Beetles fanatic, thinks you did the best last night. I disagree. You did well. You sounded good. But I have finally figured out what I don't really like about you. It is your vibrato. It is too fast for me. If the vibrato was gone, I think I might be able to get on the Casey train. But don't change your vibrato just for one passenger.

Siobhan: Hmm. I didn't like it again. You get so nasally. You swallow your sound unless you are either really high or really screaming. I don't like that at all. Maybe you just need some voice lessons to pull that out.

Lee: You did awesome and were once again the best of the night.

So, what are my rankings?

Top 3:
  1. Lee
  2. Crystal
  3. Katie
Middle 3:
  1. Andrew
  2. Casey
  3. Tim
Bottom 3:
  1. Siobhan
  2. Aaron
  3. Mike
Now for the tricky part. Who will be in the bottom 3?

I don't really know. I have been saying (and seeing) Tim and Katie for weeks now. I think Tim will land in the bottom three just because he needs to, but I don't know if Katie will. Based on last night, she shouldn't. But at this point, things aren't necessarily based on one night. And they shouldn't be.

I wouldn't be surprised to see Aaron in the bottom.

I am going to say (with little confidence): Tim, Aaron, and Siobhan.

Sincerely,

Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Monday, April 5, 2010

Dear Tim: Daddy's Shoes


Dear Tim,

You have my husband to thank for this one. As we were watching your performance last Tuesday, my husband commented that you were like a little boy walking around in your Daddy's shoes. Now, he wasn't saying that you were clomping around or ungraceful. As Ellen pointed out, you are quite sneaky on stage. He also wasn't discussing the "Deer in the Headlights" look you get on your face quite often.

No. It is just that you are really out of your league. If I pull you out of the competition and see you on stage in your high school auditorium, you are great. I am impressed and think you have a good voice. But when I watch you week after week, I see that you are just a boy trying to fill shoes you just aren't big enough for. I don't really think you will ever grow into them, either. I don't know. There is a small chance--you are young. But you aren't making the improvements the other contestants are making.

You also aren't seeming to take things seriously. Maybe you have a nervous habit where you laugh when criticized. If that is the case, I advise you to overcome that because that will be a, let's say, disruption to married life. You might be, as you say, just really happy to be on stage. If that is the case, try suppressing the laugh until you walk off. Laughing is super weird. I kind of doubt it is what Simon said. I doubt you are laughing because you know what they say doesn't matter. I mean, he is right. You have teenage girls and VFTW behind you all the way (you are their longest-running pick you know). But I don't think you are laughing because you know that you will stick around anyway. You seem like a better guy than that.

My money is on you not knowing how to respond, so you laugh. My motto is always "you can laugh or you can cry." Getting criticized week after week would lead you in one of those two situations--but try to avoid laughing until you have left the stage.



Sincerely,
Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Saturday, April 3, 2010

Dear Didi: Oh Sigh


Dear Didi,

Well, I have been putting this off. It is hard to say good-bye. But, alas, I must at some point. I wouldn't want to not say good-bye, so I had better get to it.

You were one of my top favorites (this group is quickly dwindling down). I loved your voice. I liked it best when you did stuff low-key. I am sad to see you go. I would like to think you would have grown as the show continued forward. You definitely are a better singer than some there, but we won't name any names (deer in the headlights anyone?).

Here are my favorite moments from you this season:

First is your audition:




Next is Terrified during Hollywood week:



Then we have "The Way I Am"




 And this was my favorite:




I am sad to see you go. I guess when you don't have any great performances in the Top 12 by this time, your clock is ticking (I actually really hope this to be true for someone soon). I hope to hear more from you in the future!

Sincerely,


Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Dear Bottom Three: My Reactions


Dear Bottom Three,

Sigh.

Katie, Yes, you deserved to be there. I am not surprised you were there in the least.

Didi, I worried you would be there, but hoped against hope you wouldn't be.

Tim, You are quite comfortable there, aren't you? Somehow, you are squeaking through. I know that website I won't mention pushed extra hard for you last time.

That is all I have to say on the topic right now.

Sincerely,

Photobucket
Share/Save/Bookmark
Related Posts with Thumbnails